Table of Contents
Novel Reviews
This is a page for my own personal reviews of stuff.
I am putting my reviews here both to have them preserved separate from the material/sites I am reviewing and to not impact ratings with my uninformed/quick/biased decisions.
Novel - Video Game Developer in a Cultivation World
creator: bor902
link: https://www.royalroad.com/fiction/87922/video-game-developer-in-a-cultivation-world
Review
This is an isekai Xianxia novel about a person from 2021/2022 who just retired at the age of 30(!!!) and then spent 2 years during lockdown playing a bunch of games since they had nothing else to do. As the main story starts the main protagonist gets transported to the other world via an aluminum can he threw off the balcony coming back via wind and killing him(definitely a new way of transmigration).
The first two acts are decent, but the third one was so contrived I dropped at chapter 34
The Good
The first act being creating a dark souls boss that uses armor and a spear in a world where everyone just uses swords due to soul power being easier to infuse in weapons using only one material to pass a test requiring him to create a useful “illusion room” to become an inner disciple.
The second act being a trip to a neighboring sect to gain rod techniques to help improve the dark souls boss. During the trip he gets roped into helping the sect weed out people with weak minds by recreating outlast since people with weak minds will go insane with the cultivation technique used by the sect.
The Bad
The rushed pace of the third act.
Both of these acts have reason behind them and are explainable. HOWEVER the third act isn't, currently up to where I dropped the story the plot goes as follows:
- Signed up for inter-sect tournament for people close to exiting inner disciple rank by his mentor, involuntarily, and he can't back out or he will be blocked from ranking up. (Sure, add time pressure but this is contrived.)
- The sect is being requested to make illusion rooms for the war against “zombies” from the “Dark Side” border.
- “Heavily recommended”/have to team up with another person due to the deadline.
- Everyone talented is paid a spirit stone to not work with mc. (sure)
- Decide to pair up with the neighbor that was introduced in the same chapter as the team recommendation was made. (Can't even spread plot points a few chapters.)
- Chooses The Last Of Us to base the illusion room on after finding out the zombie infection can spread.
- Starts building The Last Of Us after learning techniques to share the illusion room
- Gets called by his mentor to ask about their progress, talks about “evolving” zombies in the illusion room without talking to his teammate.
- In the middle of the meeting his mentor gets notified that the zombies are evolving.
- Next chapter we find out the zombies aren't having small mutations such as sprinter zombies, but rather large mutations such as clickers. (Not punished at all, man.)
- The next chapter he talks with his teammate in which he says “Well, actually, the zombies mutated into a variant I was already modelling the combat for”
If you can't understand why this is bad story telling, let me spell it out for you: There is no foreshadowing, no Chekhov's guns, nothing. The story is going balls to the walls with no conductor at the helm leading to what I believe are retroactive adjustments to the story such as the girl neighbor being introduced in the same chapter as the team requirement being added. The main character is also being blessed by plot armor so thick it is hard to read the text behind the shield that is protecting the entire story.
Some people in the comments also agree with me that the MC is being stupid here and getting away with it due to plot armor.
The neighbor relationship
Another thing is the relationship with the neighbor develops completely artificially. Look at the timeline here:
timeline:
- 23- neighbor enthusiastically introduces herself to mc so enthusiastically and knows too much about the mc that the mc is flustered and brushes her off.
- 27- mc sees neighbor and invites her after complementing her art, neighbor joins team.
- 31- neighbor complains mc isn't seeing them sexually then the chapter explains why that is(both are commoners as a retroactive justification).
Nothing happens with the neighbor between chapter 23 and 27 so I will ignore them. That is 4 chapters between joining the MC's party and being down to fuck or at least enough to be sexually frustrated at no interest from the MC.
The Political Comment
So far in the story there has only been one semi-disguised political comment:
“Make the Illusion Room Sect Great Again… Awesome…” - chapter 24
This is almost completely out of the blue, with no explanation what so ever in-universe.
The Fake "Art Critic" Style Of Analysis
Take this direct quote from the story(chapter 27):
“Then it's even more impressive,” Jin commented. “But, reading into it. It's an abstracted version of the inner ring that you have recently joined. You turned it into an effigy of different perspectives and the clashing colour composition of red and blue. You feel not at ease, alienated. You have recently discovered that simply because one progresses on the path of mastery, does not mean that the people one meets there will be any better than the people one has left behind. They'll simply be different.” He hummed thoughtfully, thinking about the lessons about being a good fortune-teller that he'd read about. It mostly boiled down to making general statements. He looked at the painting again. Colours clashed in an intentional manner. Long shadows were thrown in a variety of directions. No people were visible despite the fact that they should have been seen from this hill. “In essence,” he determined, “You feel alone in a world that you do not understand. Perhaps in your eyes, it disappointed some expectations.”
What does this convey to the reader? If your answer was anything other then “The author wants to sound smart” then you are wrong. The entirety of this paragraph reads like someone bullshitting their way into the good graces of somebody by being a sycophant/boot licker. Think for a moment, what does this bring to the story?
The story plays it off as him acting wise here by saying:
“He hummed thoughtfully, thinking about the lessons about being a good fortune-teller that he'd read about. It mostly boiled down to making general statements.”
But in other parts of the story it is played seriously. Take for example this quote from chapter 3:
“while it is perhaps presumptuous of me to create something so non-normative, I hope that it can be seen simply as putting forth an experiment, which wiser heads will judge the validity of.”
This reads like something one would find from a beginner writer who is trying to sound smart by using thesaurus and other resources to show off new words they have learned instead of conveying meaning.
The MC
- Generic isekai MC
- Perfect memory
- Somehow can't do anything other then rip-off games from his original dimension.
- Can change the surroundings and and designs but can't deviate from them:
In the end, he had just about enough time to mirror essentially from the game everything that he could, and maybe then later he could start adding his own things. However, individuating the product based on personal preferences, beyond the necessary ones of setting and character design could also go very wrong. After all, the game had worked very well in his last life. Why change it?
This is also another example of thesaurus coming out in the word “individuating”.
Novel - My Only Familiar Is Me
creator: Vetrax
link: https://www.royalroad.com/fiction/158801/my-only-familiar-is-mea-late-blooming-evolution
Review
Decent premise similar to or possibly inspired by self-summon, with this taking a more sci-fi take on the premise compared to the fantasy take of the other story. That is all the story has going for it though.
The main things wrong with this is the lack of character the protagonist has. He has no personality and the closest thing to a personality he reaches is the burnt out office worker side character. The main character honestly has less of a personality then some systems in other novels.
The lack of personality isn't helped by the fact that the author also seems to have ai assisted writing without disclosure or at least uses ai enough that they have absorbed the writing style of AIs such as chatgpt. This is most obvious when the author is trying to make the main character sound smart such as
“This isn't just a set of exercises, Selina. It's a controlled experiment.”
and to a lesser extent
“This is an individualized workout and nutrition program,” I explained while she studied my notes. “Specifically adjusted for Ted and Nick's metabolism and body measurements. Designed to squeeze out maximum results in the shortest possible time. You see, I'm a Trainer. And I decided my gift shouldn't work only for internal use.”
Both quotes from chapter 40.
The story otherwise is a solid “mid” aka 4-5/10 with nothing else to remark about other then it being boring.